BOOKPLATES
BOOKPLATES
THE WORLD OF EX-LIBRIS
A historical retrospective

3 MODERN TIMES
 
BOOKPLATES
3a
HERALDIC DECADENCE AND REVIVAL
1720-1950

The height of heraldic art was between the 13th and 16th centuries, both from an artistic and a utilitarian point of view. Its norms were fairly strict, both as far as content of arms and their presentation were concerned: for instance, different helm positions were supposed to correspond to degrees of nobility, as did crowns and coronets, but enforcement was difficult. As ex-libris were ‘private’ works of art, owners sometimes cheated a bit and saw to it that the artist’s composition reflected higher rank than reality. But if one talks of heraldic decadence, which is apparent in the 17th century already, one refers mainly to bad artistic heraldic usage, and to errors in the presentation of arms. These became widespread after the French revolution, as heraldry to a great extent fell into disuse. Towards the end of the 19th century, however, artists interested in heraldry, such as A.M. Hildebrandt and Otto Hupp in Germany, turned back to a purer mediaeval armorial style, and their compositions – including ex-libris – for armigerous persons regained strength and beauty. In the 20th century, new generations of artists followed suit, and although heraldic ex-libris tend to be rarer in this century than ever before, many of them are of good artistic and heraldic quality, expressing the traditional norms in pleasing modern pictorial terms.

img img
3a/1. ? (CH) HIRZEL, C3, 95 x 74, c.1720. Weg 3533.

An uncommon plate for a member of the Hirzel family of Zurich. Swiss heraldic ex-libris are sometimes a bit provincial and artistically unrefined in composition, but the heraldic tradition of that country is strong. In this plate, the shield is lopsided and the helm looks like a lamp bulb; the mantling is all wrong and the lion, meant to be a supporter, looks like a mangy cat sniffing at the shield. The arms seem to be about to fall off the mound on which they rest...
3a/2. ? (F) DE BUCHELET, C2, 65 x 56, c.1800.

The amusing personification of a lion in this ex-libris is its saving grace. But the heraldic elements are weakly drawn, and the crown seems about to fall off the shield.

img
3a/3. N. Whittock (GB) REV. BEAUCHAMP ST. JOHN, C1, 133 x 90, c.1850. F 25967.

Beauchamp St. John (1795-1856) was obviously fond of heraldry, as he asked Whittock of Oxford to put the 60 shields of his and related families on his ex-libris. But the aesthetic result is deplorable!

img img 1 / 1
3a/4. ? (D) BIBL. HAMBURG-AMERICA LINE, L, 135 x 90, 1906.

The desire for something heraldic, with its snob implications, remains alive. But the ex-libris of this maritime line brought the subject to ridicule.
3a/5. John Henry Metcalfe (GB) CHARLES HENRY L. WOODD, X1, 165 x 61, c.1880. F 32441.

A pleasing, simple treatment of a coat of arms, with a charming touch of humour. The return to woodcut from the strongly dominant copper engraving was one of the features of the late nineteenth century ex-libris revival.

img img
3a/6. George W. Eve (GB, 1855-1914) EVERARD GREENE, C1, ø 68, 1895. Viz. BNL #140.

Eve was an artist whose work was an inspiration to many of his contemporaries, and a catalogue of his bookplates – mostly, but not exclusively heraldic – was written by G. H. Viner and published in Kansas City in 1916. This masterpiece was made for Everard Green, Rouge Dragon Herald.
3a/7. C. Helard (GB) RT. HON. ARTHUR J. BALFOUR, P. C., C2, 84 x 65, 1899.

Miss Helard, whose real name was Mary Ellen Blanche Crookes (*1870, fl. 1895-1932), was the wife of Arthur Fox-Davies, an important herald and heraldry expert of the time. Following the fashion set by C. W. Sherborn (Viz. 3b/1-3) and G. W. Eve (Viz. 3a/6), she engraved a large number of fine heraldic ex-libris of which this plate for Balfour, who was some time British Prime Minister.

img img
3a/8. Edward E. Dorling (GB, 1863-1943) & Sir Emery Walker (GB, 1851-1933) SIR WALTER SHERBURNE PRIDEAUX, C2, 100 x 62, c.1920.
An excellent designer and a great engraver combined efforts for this fine heraldic ex-libris. Note the ribbon mantling, which gives a more modern flavour to the plate, although it was already occasionally used in mediaeval heraldry.
3a/9. Claude Jeanneret (CH, 1886-1979) DONALD LINDSAY GALBREATH, X1, 130 x 98, c.1920.

Jeanneret was one of the first Swiss artists to return to the powerful mediaeval woodcut heraldic style. Many of his ex-libris are hand-coloured or printed in colour with different blocks, but he chose this simple and graphically strong image for D. L. Galbreath, F.S.A., whose Manuel d’Héraldique (1924) remains a standard work today, several times reprinted (see also 4g/25).

img img
3a/10. Jaques Buser-Kobler (CH, 1884-1945) SCHÄFER, X1/4, 144 x 73, c.1930.

This Swiss artist, who signed his name BuKo, made a large number of ex-libris with excellent heraldic qualities. However, his reputation was tarnished by the fact that he made many ex-libris for high German dignitaries before and during the 2nd World War, including one for Hitler.
3a/11. Paul Boesch (CH, 1889-1969) DR. FRANZ R. FISCHER, X1, 115 x 82, c.1930.

Boesch was the most prolific of the Swiss heraldic woodcut artists, and made well over 100 ex-libris. His quality was that he did not try to return to mediaeval aesthetics, but developed a modern heraldic expression with the qualities of mediaeval style.

img img
3a/12. Stephen Gooden (GB, 1892-1955) LORD FAIRHAVEN, C2 , 97 x 65, c.1940

Gooden was an outstanding master of engraving, without doubt one of the greatest of our century. When he dealt with heraldry, the style and composition is superb. He also made another ex-libris for the same person, with the full coat of arms. See also 4f/19.
3a/13. Max Eberle (CH, 1900-1987) IPSE, X1, 82 x 50, c.1950.

The following generation is well represented by Eberle, whose woodcut crest plate is an example of good modern heraldry.

End of 3a



| Ex-Libris | Art Prints | Kara Art Home |